Hey guys, I have a second channel now called CDTVThaG, originals on this channel will know
that that name is not serious and from an inside joke, but anyway I uploaded my first
reaction to this album on that channel, so I've left the link in the description and
after this video you can watch my first reaction to this project on my new music reaction channel.
Thanks for listening.
So, ? Is the new album from XXXTomatoSauce, and as you guys know I've not exactly been
a fan of X's music.
I've liked some songs here and there, but I've mostly had a negative experience with
his music.
So did this change my view of it?
Well this is CDTVProductions and is ? By XXXTerraflop good?
Let's talk about it.
Intro: XXXTENTACION "Moonlight"
Now I do wanna start this off by saying X is a pretty unique artist.
I will say that I haven't heard an album like this all year, and even last year excluding
his own 17 project.
He himself is unique, but the problem is the majority of this album is nothing new from
him.
He promised us in the incredibly corny and pandering intro that this album would be much
more versatile, much more different than his last album 17, but it's really not.
By the way speaking of that intro, the whole Explanation thing is a horrible idea, let
the music speak for itself, don't tell us what we should feel about it.
But, let's get back to this album not really being too different from 17.
Alone Pt. 3, the remedy for a broken heart, Numb, Love Yourself, before I close my eyes,
these all sound like they were lifted right out of the 17 leftovers pile.
(Clip: XXXTENTACION "ALONE PART 3").
They have the same stripped down acoustic instrumentation, the same mumbled singing
vocals that don't really convey much emotion, and of course lyrics that have as much depth
as the amount of water left in this glass.
It's lyrically very shallow for the majority of its runtime.
Even on the straight up rapping tracks like Goin Down or Floor 555, X barely drops any
nice bars.
Then you have the painfully surface level lyrics of songs like Pain = Best Friend, or
Numb.
These songs could be written by a pseudo intellectual teenager.
X genuinely seems like a depressed person so I don't see why he can't translate
it to his music well at all.
Now like I said, a good handful of the tracks sound like they're from 17, so what about
the ones that don't?
Well I quite liked the song Moonlight, particularly the hook, until I realized it had the exact
same cadence as his song A Ghetto Christmas Carol.
Floor 555 is distorted to shit so it doesn't sound much different from all X's old SoundCloud
music.
So much of this is just deja vu.
Sure the beats do have a bit of variety here, you've got the acoustic instrumentals from
17, you've got the banger instrumental in Going Down, you've got the very weird Spanish
pop song called I don't even speak Spanish lol, but all these sounds make the album sound
so thrown together.
There's no cohesiveness to it.
None of the songs really connect and it just feels like a random assortment of music from
X.
And then let's talk about the run time of all of these tracks.
A lot of these are so short, that it doesn't even really feel like any of the tracks have
an impact.
One of the tracks I actually quite enjoy on here
called Schizophrenia has this weird, chilling vibe to it.
X whispers his vocals at some parts, then sings them, then screams them, and it feels
like a rollercoaster.
The problem is, it's over so quickly.
1 minute and 20 seconds passes, the track ends and even though I liked what went on
during the run time, I just thought; is that it?
The lengths of all the songs really don't help them.
So I know, that was quite a lot of negatives, but there is some stuff I enjoyed on here
and I do think it was better than 17.
For one, the track Infinity with Joey Bada$$ was one of the biggest highlights on here.
If this is a peek into what the X and Joey Bada$$ collab tape will sound like, then I'm
ready.
It's over this 90s beat that's more Joey Bada$$ than it is X, but X sounds really good
over beats like this.
(Clip: XXXTENTACION "Infinity (888) [feat.
Joey Bada$$]").
I wish we had more stuff like this on here, because that track was brilliant.
Not to mention he has a fantastic flow on that track.
I also kinda liked the song Money, which surprisingly featured Matt Ox who actually did a decent
enough job, you know talking about his 12 year old gang and all that.
But the vocals weren't that bad at all.
And honestly my favourite tracks from this were 2 that I'd already heard, Changes and
SAD!
Both of those tracks are incredibly catchy, and actually have nice vocals throughout the
entirety of their length.
Also the closing song to the album, Before I Close My Eyes, is one I really enjoyed.
Even though it does have that acoustic sound, it's so relaxing, and X's vocals contribute
to that effect, rather than being sad mumbling.
But I'm not sure if there's much else I like about this album.
At most, I'd listen to about 6 of these tracks more in the future.
But as a whole, this album is just a really random collection of songs that aren't individually
that great in the first place.
It sounds so disjointed, and whilst I didn't like 17, at least it had a cohesive sound.
This has better songs overall than 17, the production value is definitely slightly higher
and occasionally the vocals are very good such as the verse on Moonlight where his vocals
sounded beautiful, but it isn't as organised.
I'm gonna give ? by XXXTickleMyToes a 3/10.
It really is quite a weak album, and it honestly feels longer than it actually is.
X's vocals haven't changed much at all since the last album, and the whole thing
is just a slow moving slog to get through.
I am giving it points though because a couple of the beats were very nice, and there are
2 or 3 great tracks on here.
It's a shame because I genuinely thought I would love
this album after really enjoying SAD!, but that unfortunately doesn't seem to be the
case.
So
what did you guys think of this album?
(Outro)
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét