Do you listen to this talk
Which warns about the additions to our history
and the lies in our religion and sect
and even in the sect of our brothers the Sunni
They are equal, I haven't differentiated between the lies amongst the Shia and Sunni
A person has come Ayatollah Sayyid Kamal al Hayderi
He's said that there is a large amount of our tradition
which are fabricated and are Israiliyaat (ahadith which have entered into the books from other religious orders)
we have to research and re-examine them
I claim that our traditions
or most of them
the Shia narrative traditions
They are fabricated and have been narrated to us from Ka'ab al Ahbar from the Christians, Jews and Magians
Even Tafsir al Qummi (is from the fabricated sources)
(Another instance)Also linked to Sayyid al Khui
A big Marja and teacher of the jurists (fuqaha)
From one of his attendees (of his lectures)
When he asked about Mafatih al Jinan
He (Khui) said this is Mafatih al Qummi
What does that mean It isn't Mafatih al Jinan
There are fabrications in Mafatih al Jinan, ofcourse some parts are right
Ayatollah Shaykh Nasir Makarim Shirazi - one of the Maraji of Qum - came out with a view
and these are his words
The book (mafatih al Jinan) in its current form and its contents were suitable for the time of Sh Abbas Qummi (compiler of mafatih)
and was appropriate for that time
as for this present moment, we will publish the book in accordance to our times
where we will omit the weak narrations
Will you dare call Ayatollah Makarim Shirazi a Kafir??
I'm not challenging you But i'm saying you are smaller than that
Ay Makarim Shirazi will also re-publish the book Bihar al Anwar
and come out with 6 volumes as compared to the original 110 volumes
only 6 volumes
What does all this show?
It just shows how some fanciful stories and dreams are used to justify lies on the Ahlul Bayt
All the sects have fabrications
Our Sunni brothers have more fabrications than we have
The balanced God conscious person from amongst the Sunni and Shia
must stand up and say from the 6 (Sunni) Sahih books is filled with lies against the Prophet
and the 4 Shia books and (in addition to and) especially Bihar al Anwar, are filled with lies about the Ahlul Bayt and the prophet
Ayatollah Rayshehri - the representative of Ay Khomeini and now the representative of Ay Khameini - has critiqued it (mafatih) also
Has anyone dared to criticise Ayatollah Rayshehri? of course not
Sh Rayshehri in his book 'Ahlul Bayt in the Kitab and Sunna' pg 130
he criticises Hadith Kisa and considers it invalid
a fabrication in Mafatih al Jinan
Does anyone have the guts to say anything against him?.. ofcourse not ...
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét